If the New York Giants use their first-round pick in the 2025 NFL Draft on a quarterback, it could signal a major reset for the franchis e.
After a disappointing 2023 season and even worse results in 2024, the team is desperate for a fresh start. The move to select a high-profile quarterback could be an indication that general manager Joe Schoen and head coach Brian Daboll are under pressure to quickly turn things around and create a competitive roster. But the question remains: will a rookie quarterback provide an immediate solution, or will the team need to temper expectations and be patient with their new signal caller?
Rookie quarterbacks, even those with immense potential, often face a steep learning curve. The transition from college to the NFL can be challenging, with increased speed, complexity, and pressure. Even top-tier quarterbacks like Trevor Lawrence or Justin Fields experienced growing pains early in their careers. For the Giants, this would likely mean early struggles in 2025, both for the player and the team as a whole. It is not uncommon for rookie quarterbacks to endure a series of ups and downs throughout their first season, and it could take multiple months before they find any consistency.
In the short term, a new quarterback could add some excitement and optimism, but the team’s performance on the field may not immediately reflect those hopes. The 2025 season could end up being another year of rebuilding, with the rookie signal caller facing growing pains and the coaching staff focusing on development rather than immediate success. This raises the question of how long the Giants can afford to wait for a rookie to fully adjust to the NFL and begin leading the team toward contention.
Ultimately, if the Giants take a quarterback early in the 2025 draft, it might not represent an immediate “franchise reset” in terms of winning games right away. Instead, it could be the start of a long-term project to build around a promising young quarterback. The challenge for Schoen and Daboll will be to balance the need for short-term success with the patience required for a rookie to develop into a franchise player. The clock is ticking, but how quickly the Giants can turn things around will depend on the long-term vision they set with their new quarterback.
